Threefold Advocate - JBU Student Newspaper

Pumpkin pie or chocolate cake: What dishes are making it to your table this Thanksgiving?

Written by Kate Hobbs | Nov 19, 2026, 2:00:04 PM

Thanksgiving is a holiday of family, friends and togetherness — until it comes to what’s going to be baking in the oven. Then all the warm fuzziness of the autumn holiday is suddenly replaced by controversial hot takes, opinions and die-hard family traditions.

Many piously follow the traditional turkey dinner, whether for taste, stubbornness or just nostalgia. Others, sick of the same-old-same-old, throw every tradition out the window, opting for a different cuisine entirely… lobster, anyone? Meanwhile, some families shoot for the stars, cooking every Thanksgiving dish imaginable to please the masses.

No matter the spread, what inspired the Thanksgiving meal?

Popularized in elementary school, the story goes that the Plymouth Colony Pilgrims originated the Thanksgiving holiday. Their three-day harvest celebration in 1621 alongside the Wampanoag Native Americans was a chance to be thankful for being alive. Their meal looked a bit different than the twenty-first century. Turkey possibly made an appearance, but their meal more likely consisted of venison, corn and even seafood. Pumpkin pie was in its primitive stage: for the pilgrims, dessert was probably a hollowed out gourd with spices inside and baked over a fire.

Thanks to the passage of time and advanced technology, Thanksgiving meals look quite a bit different in America today.

First up, the main dish: will turkey take the crown, or does ham claim the top meat spot? Some cover their turkey in salty, savory gravy, while others love a sweet, honey-baked ham.

Potatoes are a source of contention on multiple levels. Are they sweet? Mashed? Doused in gooey marshmallows or a sugary pecan streusel?

Another matchup: stuffing versus dressing. It may be hard to spot the difference between the two because stuffing and dressing recipes’ may seem fundamentally similar (usually a mix of bread, vegetables and herbs), but they can be slightly different depending on family recipes.

Nothing cuts through the array of savory foods like cranberry sauce. The debate between the jelly or sauce version typically boils down to preference, but the western US typically favors the can, while the citrusy sauce is more common in the northeast.

The Northeast United States, despite being geographically near to the original Thanksgiving dinner, is ironically more unusual. New Englanders enjoy creamed onions, concord grape pie and Indian pudding.

Southern cooking (and maybe John Madden) is to thank for the famous turducken: duck stuffed in chicken stuffed in turkey — a poultry trinity that hails from Louisiana. An eyebrow-raising side, macaroni and cheese, also appears at southerners’ Thanksgiving meals with sweet potato pie for dessert — except for Georgia, who reportedly voted key lime pie as their favorite turkey-day pie.

As for Arkansas, chocolate cake was voted the most popular Thanksgiving dessert. It pleases like no pie can. Who needs pumpkin?

Whether you’re a proud Thanksgiving purist or if you’re willing to see some newcomers on the dining room table, Thanksgiving still serves as a perfect opportunity to rest, reflect and enjoy delicious food in the company of those loved most. Happy Thanksgiving!

For those wanting to feel like a true Arkansan this Thanksgiving, check out a traditional Arkansas Thanksgiving Menu:

  • Ham, Turkey or Venison
  • Cornbread Dressing
  • Eggplant Casserole
  • Fried Apples
  • Green Rice
  • Sweet Potato Casserole
  • Buttermilk Pecan Pie

 Photo by Megan Watson on Unsplash